Workshop: Remote operation of CAVs 2023

Automated  bus.
Photo: My Weidel/VTI)

The workshop was held on 4th June 2023, as a full-day event in conjunction with the IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium 2023 (IV). This was the third workshop on remote operation organized in conjunction with the IV conference. The previous two workshops were organized under the title “Road Vehicle Teleoperation” at IV'21 and IV'22.

This workshop intends to serve as a common research arena to initiate multi-disciplinary discussions on different components around remote operation of intelligent connected and automated vehicles on the road. Road vehicles of interest include (but are not limited to) connected and automated vehicles that are passenger cars, trucks, and shuttles or buses. In this context, we assume there is a remote operator(s) who operates this vehicle(s) from a distance via wireless communication network. The remote operation is done at a remote operation station, where necessary interfaces for remotely operating the vehicle(s) are provided.

The workshop consists of two sections: during the first half-day, presentations will set the stage on the current state of the art regarding remote operation of vehicles. Workshop papers will be presented and invited speakers will state their latest insights on this hot topic. During the second half-day, an interactive format will enable an in-depth debate in which workshop participants from industry and research across multiple countries will share experiences and ideas, and discuss design and technology goals for the future. We will discuss prospective research directions and develop ideas on how to tackle them.

IEEE IV 2023 – IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (ieee-iv.org)

Workshop program

Download program Pdf, 202.3 kB.

Agenda for the workshop.

Time  

Program

8:00‑8:30

Registration

8:30‑8:45

Opening session

Maytheewat Aramrattana (VTI, Sweden) and Andreas Schrank (DLR, Germany)

8:45‑9:15

The need for a socio-technical systems perspective on remote operation of highly automated vehicles

Jonas Andersson (RISE Research Institutes of Sweden, Sweden) [Online presenter]

9:15‑9:45

Hello Tower, where are we heading? – State of the art in remote operation of automated vehicles and future outlook

Azra Habibovic (Scania, Sweden) [Online presenter]

9:45‑10:10

Coffee break

10:10‑10:40

On-road remote driving, situation awareness, and limits of teleoperation

Marek Vanžura (George Mason University, USA) [Online presenter]

10:40‑11:10

Assisting the Automation: User-Centered Design and User Evaluation of a Prototypical Workplace for the Technical Supervisor

Andreas Schrank (German Aerospace Center (DLR), Germany)

11:10‑11:40

Remote driving operation and remote automated vehicle operation

Maytheewat Aramrattana (The Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute, Sweden)

11:40‑12:40

Interactive session 1

12:40‑13:40

Lunch

13:40‑14:10

A Survey of Teleoperation: Driving Feedback (workshop paper)

Lin Zhao (KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden)

14:10‑14:40

Vehicle Teleoperation: A Long-Term View

Tao Zhang (The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), USA)

14:40‑15:10

Principles for Human Remote Support of Automated Driving Systems: Development of ISO/TC 22/SC 39 TS 17691

Joanne Harbluk, Transport Canada [Online Presenter]

15:10‑15:40

Coffee break

15:40‑16:10

Remote Operations of Unmanned Systems: How it started vs. How’s it going

Prof. Mary “Missy” Cummings (George Mason University, USA) [Online presenter]

16:10‑16:40

High-fidelity Teleoperation for Heavy Duty and Fast-moving Vehicles

Sanat Mharolkar (Nanyang Technological University, Singapore)

16:40‑17:40

Interactive session 2

17:40‑17:50

Closing

Maytheewat Aramrattana and Andreas Schrank

About the workshop

IEEE ITSS members will receive a free workshops day only registration.

Title: The need for a socio-technical systems perspective on remote operation of highly automated vehicles

Presenter: Jonas Andersson (RISE Research Institutes of Sweden, Sweden)

Abstract:
Human assistance and occasional teleoperation of road vehicles is (still) required to help highly automated vehicles when the vehicle automation is not capable of handling a situation. The safety and efficiency of the road traffic system is therefore likely to be dependent on remote human operator work for some time to come. The characteristics of operator work is shaped not only by the capability of the automation, but to a great extent also by other human-technology-organizational factors. The talk will address the need for a socio-technical systems approach when designing systems for remote operation of highly automated vehicles, and how this can be achieved.

Title: On-road remote driving, situation awareness, and limits of teleoperation

Presenter: Marek Vanžura (George Mason University, USA) [Online]

Abstract:
This talk will present findings and results from the project Situational awareness in drivers of teleoperated vehicles which experimentally studied the limits of on-road teleoperation in relation to both a driver's situation awareness and the capabilities of wireless networks. The results relevant to road safety were then reflected in the design of a new ergonomic remote control station for on-road teleoperation.

Title: A Survey of Teleoperation: Driving Feedback

Presenter: Lin Zhao (KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden)

Abstract:
Teleoperation can be regarded as an effective backup system for self-driving vehicles, which could take over vehicle control in some special scenarios that the automated vehicles could not handle. However, there are still many challenges in teleoperation, such as low situation awareness. This could potentially be dangerous in some extreme situations. However, it could be effectively improved by providing suitable driving feedbacks. Hence, this article provides a timely and comprehensive review of existing and possible driving feedback techniques in teleoperation. They are presented from the point of view of video feedback, steering force feedback, motion-cueing feedback, audio and vibration feedback, and other non-conventional feedback modes. Then, the current challenges, future trends and opportunities in teleoperation are presented and discussed.

Title: Remote Operations of Unmanned Systems: How it started vs. How’s it going

Presenter: Prof. Mary “Missy” Cummings (George Mason University, USA) [Online]

Abstract:
Remote operations has evolved significantly over the past twenty years in supervising unmanned aerial vehicles, but unfortunately these lessons have not been learned in the surface transportation community for unmanned ground vehicles. In this talk, Prof. Cummings will detail how self-driving cars need to adapt lessons learned from aviation and what gaps need immediate attention.

Title: High-fidelity Teleoperation for Heavy Duty and Fast-moving Vehicles

Presenter: Sanat Mharolkar (Nanyang Technological University, Singapore)

Abstract:
Making vehicles fully autonomous is still a big challenge in a world as unstructured as ours. There are many situations on the road as well as off the road that require human intervention and control. Therefore, most regulations require a safety driver to be onboard an autonomous vehicle at all times to monitor the situation and take control when required. A logical step towards greater autonomy and removing the need for an onboard safety driver is teleoperation or tele-driving. Apart from being a good backup for autonomous vehicles, teleoperation is also a good alternative for situations in which a human driver is at risk or in an uncomfortable environment, such as excavation, construction, mining and cold chain logistics. Teleoperation of such a variety of vehicle types has many challenges, especially when operating heavy duty or fast-moving vehicles. We present a high-fidelity teleoperation system that is specifically designed to overcome these challenges. Using a multi-camera system for wide-angle views and blind spot coverage along with a motion platform that mimics the vehicle’s motion and accelerations, we can provide a realistic and immersive driving experience that makes tele-driving significantly easier and natural. The motion and video synchronization also helps prevent motion sickness for drivers who need to teleoperate over long periods of time. Our system is specifically designed to promise low end-to-end latency and low bandwidth consumption, so that it can work over various network connections such as 4G, 5G and long-range Wi-Fi.

Jonas Andersson, PhD
RISE Research Institutes of Sweden, Sweden

Jonas Andersson has an M.Sc. in Industrial Design & Production Engineering from Luleå University of Technology and holds a PhD in Human-Technology-Design from Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden. Jonas has more than 15 years of experience in research and development on human-automation interaction and systems design in a range of domains such as automotive, maritime, process- and nuclear industries. He is currently acting unit manager and senior researcher in the Humanized Autonomy team at RISE Research Institutes of Sweden in Gothenburg.

Marek Vanzura
George Mason University, USA

Marek Vanzura received his Ph.D. in 2019 from Masaryk University in Brno, Czechia, with a dissertation on the impacts of remote operations on the minds and mental health of military drone pilots. From 2018 to 2023, he was the Head of Autonomous Driving Department at CDV - Transport Research Centre in Brno, where he led several national and international projects, including a project focused on remote driving (teleoperation). Since 2023, he has been a faculty member at George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia.

Andreas Schrank, M.Sc.
German Aerospace Center (DLR), Institute of Transportation Systems, Germany

Andreas Schrank is a Human Factors researcher at the German Aerospace Center (DLR), Institute of Transportation Systems. He obtained his Master’s degree in Psychology from Heidelberg University, Germany, while also studying in Istanbul, Turkey, and Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA. In his research, Andreas Schrank focuses on human-machine interaction in the realm of automated driving with an emphasis on the Human Factor in teleoperated automated vehicles, particularly regarding roles, tasks, systems, and user-centered interfaces. He is involved in major EU research projects like “Hi-Drive” as well as several German national research projects on this topic.

Maytheewat Aramrattana, PhD
The Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute (VTI), Sweden

Maytheewat Aramrattana is a researcher at Vehicle Systems and Driving Simulation unit at The Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute (VTI). He received his B.Eng. (2010) in Electrical Engineering from Kasetsart University (Thailand), and a M.Sc. (2013) and Ph.D. (2018) in Computer Science and Engineering from Halmstad University (Sweden). His current research interests are in modeling and simulation of cooperative intelligent transport systems, and teleoperation of connected and automated vehicles.

Lin Zhao
KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden

Lin Zhao was born in Hebei, China. He received his M.S. degree in automotive engineering from Chongqing University, Chongqing, China in 2019. He is currently working toward his Ph.D. degree at the Department of Engineering Mechanics, School of Engineering Sciences, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden.

Dr. Tao Zhang
The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), USA

Dr. Tao Zhang has been leading research, product development, and corporate strategies for over 30 years. He is now managing the Transformational Networks and Services research group at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). He was the CTO for the Smart Connected Vehicles business at Cisco Systems, and the Chief Scientist and Director of multiple research groups focused on mobile and vehicular networking at Telcordia Technologies (formerly Bell Communications Research). He cofounded three industry consortia, including the OpenFog Consortium. Tao holds over 100 patents awarded globally and coauthored two books on vehicular networks and all-IP mobile networks. He has cofounded several successful international conferences. Tao served as the CIO and a Board Governor of the IEEE Communications Society, a Distinguished Lecturer of the IEEE Vehicular Technology Society, and an editor or guest editor for numerous journals or their special issues. Dr. Zhang is a Fellow of the IEEE, a Fellow of the Society for Information Reuse and Integration, and a Fellow of the Asia-Pacific Artificial Intelligence Academy.

Prof. Mary “Missy” Cummings
George Mason University, USA

Professor Mary (Missy) Cummings received her B.S. in Mathematics from the US Naval Academy in 1988, her M.S. in Space Systems Engineering from the Naval Postgraduate School in 1994, and her Ph.D. in Systems Engineering from the University of Virginia in 2004. A naval officer and military pilot from 1988-1999, she was one of the U.S. Navy's first female fighter pilots. She is a Professor in the George Mason University College of Engineering and Computing and is the director of the Mason Autonomy and Robotics Center (MARC). She is an American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) Fellow, and recently served as the senior safety advisor to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Her research interests include the application of artificial intelligence in safety-critical systems, assured autonomy, human-systems engineering, and the ethical and social impact of technology.

Sanat Mharolkar
Nanyang Technological University, Singapore

Sanat Mharolkar is a PhD student and researcher in the School of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, NTU Singapore. His interests are in robotics and autonomous vehicles, specifically in context-aware perception and high-level decision making for autonomy as well as teleoperation.

  • Maytheewat Aramrattana, Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute (VTI), Sweden
  • Jonas Jansson, Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute (VTI), Sweden
  • Andreas Schrank, German Aerospace Center (DLR), Germany
  • Michael Oehl, German Aerospace Center (DLR), Germany

In our workshop’s definition of remote operation (or often called teleoperation), we consider three modes: 1) remote monitoring, 2) remote assistance, and 3) remote driving. Remote monitoring is when a remote operator oversees an operation of a vehicle or vehicles in a fleet, to ensure that the vehicles operate safely. Remote assistance includes situations when a vehicle requests an assistance during its normal operation. For instance, a vehicle encounters an ambiguous object while driving autonomously, the vehicle then requests assistance from the remote operator in order to confirm whether it is safe to overtake the object. Therefore, in this case, the remote operator assists the vehicle without taking direct control of the vehicle. Lastly, remote driving refers to situations when the remote operator takes over control of a vehicle and manually operates the vehicle by directly executing dynamic driving tasks (e.g., steering, accelerating, breaking).

Several core components are required to create a system for remote operation of road vehicles described above, which are, for instance:

  1. Connectivity between a remotely operated vehicle(s) and a remote operator
  2. Human-machine interface for remote operators at remote stations
  3. Feedback from vehicles to remote operators
  4. Laws and regulations for remote operation of vehicles

Therefore, the main topics of interest can be summarized as follows:

  • Connectivity challenges in road vehicle remote operation
  • Human factors in road vehicle remote operation
  • Human-machine interface for the remote operation of road vehicles
  • Laws and regulations related to road vehicle remote operation
  • Vehicle design and technology to support vehicle remote operation
  • Remote monitoring of automated vehicles
  • Remote assistance of automated vehicles
  • Remote driving of (automated) vehicles
  • System architecture for road vehicle remote operation

We will also welcome other topics, that are relevant to the field but not listed above.

THE IEEE INTELLIGENT VEHICLES SYMPOSIUM (IV 2023) is the premier annual forum organized by the IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Society (ITSS). Researchers, academicians, and practitioners from universities, industry, and government agencies are invited to submit their latest research papers, simulation challenges, and applications on Intelligent Vehicles and Intelligent Vehicle Infrastructures. The conference will feature Plenary Talks, Technical Sessions, Poster Sessions, Tutorials, Workshops, Exhibition and Industrial Demo Challenges. The technical presentations are characterized by a single session format so that all attendees remain in a single room for multilateral communications in an informal atmosphere. Workshops will be offered on the first day followed by three days of presentations and a vehicle demonstration day. An exhibition area will be available for the presentation of products and projects. The IEEE IV 2023 will take place in Anchorage Alaska, USA and will offer a competitive Technical Program and a Memorable Social Program.

IEEE Intelligent Vehicles 2023 External link.

Important dates 2023

  • February 01, 2023: Workshop paper submission deadline (firm deadline, no extension)
  • March 30, 2023: Workshop Paper Notification of Acceptance
  • April 22, 2023: Workshop Final Paper Submission Deadline
  • June 4, 2023: Workshop day
Last updated: